Friday, December 2, 2011

Watching the Watchmen Watch the Watchmen Watching the Watchmen Watch the Watchmen (Or Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo)




"I really liked it," said my girlfriend as we exited the IMAX theater in Rochester, NY, where we had just attended a special midnight showing of Watchmen along with three hundred or so of our fellow college students. "But while I was watching it I wasn't thinking, 'Wow, this is a really good movie,' I was thinking, 'Wow, the book this movie is based on must be a really good book.'"

I couldn't have said it better myself.

Zack Snyder's Watchmen can hardly be called a movie any more than it can called Zack Snyder's, for the supposedly "visionary" director of the fun 2004 remake of Dawn of the Dead and 2006's chest-thumping action epic 300, also based on a graphic novel, seems in this case less a director than one of those ancient Benedictine monks, hunched over a podium, reverently illuminating a sacred text.

Snyder's sacred text of choice: Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' seminal graphic novel of the same name, originally published in single-issue form by DC Comics over the course of 1986 and 1987. (Moore famously refused to attach his name to any future adaptations of his work after the box office and critical failures of From Hell in 2001 and The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen in 2003, a policy to which he continues to adhere even after the comparative success of V for Vendetta in 2005. I wonder if he will renege after what is likely to be the phenomenal box office success of Hollywood's latest attempt, released March 6th.)

Despite its palpable, back pain-inducing length (I saw little blue lights flicker on and off several times as people slipped their cell phones discreetly out of their pockets to check the time) all five of my party remained apparently engaged for the full 163 minutes, which struck me as odd; typically, if a movie failed to distract its viewers from the passage of time, that means it failed to entertain them.

Not in this case. Somehow, Watchmen inspires its viewers to endure the back pain and the sleeping buttocks even as they remain acutely aware of them. It is not unsimilar in this way to the experience of reading the entire graphic novel in one sitting (I should know, that's how I read it): even as your neck aches from poring over its 416 pages and your eyes burn from scanning all the diminutive text in its various emotive fonts, you grow only more stalwart, determined not to be defeated by the enormity of the task.

Or perhaps "entertain" is simply the wrong word. Watchmen is more impressive than it is entertaining. Snyder reportedly set out to produce a more faithful adaptation of a source material than had ever before been produced, and in that he seems to have been successful. Taken thus, as an experiment in stretching the limits of page to screen translation, it is truly an awesome feat to behold. He gets every detail right, from the chromatic scheme (secondary colors such as orange and purple as opposed to the traditional primary colors of comic books such as the blue and red of Superman's cape and tights) to the sound a would be assassin makes when he is punched in the stomach (described onomatopoetically in the graphic novel as "hugYUH").




The credit for little else of what makes Watchmen watchable belongs to Snyder, however, as characters that should have been wooden robbed of the internal monologues that flesh them out in the graphic novel are brought to nuanced life by what must be one of the finest ensembles of actors ever assembled for a lowly comic book flick.

While you won't find any one performance as brilliant as Heath Ledger's in last summer's The Dark Knight, there are the always appealing Patrick Wilson (Little Children, HBO's Angels in America) as a nebbishy Night Owl and Billy Crudup (Almost Famous, Stage Beauty) as a dispassionate Dr. Manhattan, both Tony award winners.

There are also:
  • Jackie Earle Haley (Little Children, All the King's Men), an until recently obscure character actor of distinct visage, as the sociopathic Rorschach.
  • Malin Akerman (27 Dresses, Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle), a young and upcoming starlet of equally distinct—ahem—other assets, as the slinky Silk Spectre II.
  • Jeffrey Dean Morgan (P.S. I Love You, ABC's Grey's Anatomy), a dead ringer for Javier Bardem, who I assume was unavailable, as the cigar-smoking, scotch-drinking Comedian.
  • Matthew Goode (Match Point, Brideshead Revisited), a suave Brit the extent of whose stunt work has been previously restricted to particularly difficult to execute tennis backhand shots, as Aryan poster child Ozymandias.


Akerman, almost certainly cast for her looks rather than her talent, is the weak link. Her teenage girlish mannerisms are distracting, her uniform line delivery drains a pivotal exchange with Dr. Manhattan of the emotional punch it should have packed, and her evident pleasure at her own admittedly considerable sex appeal is inconsistent with the character of a young woman frustrated with what she perceives as the demeaning role of superheroine-cum-bombshell thrust upon her by a controlling mother, the original Silk Spectre (the much sexier Carla Gugino).

Her scenes with Wilson play nicely, however, perhaps because Wilson draws genuine spontaneity out of her with his own, perhaps because all that is required of her in those scenes is to provide the kind of sexual foil that Dan Dreiberg (Night Owl's alter ego) sees as out of his league, thus becoming endearingly bumbling whenever she is around and thereby providing the audience with some much needed comic relief.

Which brings me to the plot: It is 1985 in an alternate reality America. Nixon is in the midst of his fifth term as president and the country is on the brink of nuclear war with Russia. A giddy opening credits sequence set to Bob Dylan's "The Times They Are A-Changin'" informs us of an alternate history in which superheros have played an integral role in shaping our society (S&M leather-clad superheroine Silhouette replaces the American sailor kissing the nurse in the iconic WWII photograph, then later they both show up murdered in the bed they presumably shared, the words "lesbian whores" scrawled across the wall in blood; we witness the assassination of JFK in unflinching slow motion, then pull back to reveal none other than a rifle wielding Comedian perched on the proverbial grassy knoll). Vigilantism has since been outlawed, and only Rorschach remains active, his face concealed by a white stocking mask across which black ink blots continually ooze and shift, inviting viewers to project whatever emotions we will.




When the Comedian is murdered Rorschach naturally assumes that somebody is picking off costumed heroes and begins to investigate. Eventually, however, we learn the Comedian was killed for having stumbled onto a much larger, darker scheme. Without giving away the ending, it suffices to say that the moral of the story seems to be that sometimes the only way to prevent evil is to commit evil.

In the graphic novel, Moore softens what might otherwise be an oppressively nihilistic world view by including subplots that center around peripheral civilian characters, the often touching details of which lend it a humanity that is markedly absent from the film. So cynically detached are we that even when the entire population of New York City is killed in a weird sort of bright blue electromagnetic explosion our only reaction is disappointment over the lameness of the special effect, especially after how consistently impressive they have been so far: bad guys explode in confetti showers of shredded flesh and sinew, a giant, whirling UFO spontaneously crystallizes out of the dust of Mars and rises like the impossibly intricate inner workings of a clock at Dr. Manhattan's telekinetic command.

Nothing, however, is quite as remarkable as Dr. Manhattan himself. Naked, musclebound, bald and blue, he might have looked ridiculous on screen. But the folks at Sony Imageworks pull it off. When during an origin sequence set to unsettling effect to Philip Glass's "Prophecies" he materializes for the first time, floating and effulgent in a Christlike pose above the heads of a cafeteria full of stunned onlookers, we share their wonder. Jaded moviegoers that we are, when's the last time you uttered the word "wow" in a movie theater?




Unfortunately, Snyder botches the action sequences, glorifying the violence with the same hyper-stylized slow-motion technique he used for 300. For that film it worked. For this one it is egregiously inappropriate. The violence in Watchmen should be gritty and unpleasant, not cool. It should leave the same bad taste in the viewers' mouths as it leaves in its perpetrators', with the exception of course of the sadistic Rorschach and the remorseless (or is he?) Comedian.

For example, in one scene Dreiberg and Sally Jupiter (Silk Spectre II's alter ego) are assaulted by a gang of thugs on their way home from dinner. To protect themselves they must resort to the martial arts skills they haven't used since they retired, and perhaps inevitably they get carried away.

In the graphic novel, when the thugs lie bloody and broken at their feet, Dreiberg and Jupiter shy away from each other's gaze, ashamed.

Snyder completely misses the point. He shoots the fight like pornography, and afterward has Wilson and Akerman lock eyes intensely, panting, as if about to start making out.

When they finally do have a sex a few scenes later it is nothing short of painful. Snyder again employs a slow motion approach, focusing first on Akerman's leather-booted legs wrapped around Wilson's waist, and then on her impeccably made-up face contorted with pleasure, all while Leonard Cohen's self consciously hokey "Hallelujah" plays obtrusively in the background.

Thank God the awkwardness is diffused at the last second by a flame thrower-as-orgasm gag or else I might have given up on the movie right then and there.

In short, yes, Watchmen is flawed. Most ambitious movies are. But I give it credit just for being ambitious. After all, they said a Watchmen movie couldn't be made, and now, imperfect though it may be, one has. Someday another visionary young filmmaker may wish to improve upon Snyder's attempt.

Lucky for him someone broke the ice.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

The Comic Book Rack (Get It? It's a Pun!)




Upon learning the possibly fraudulent news that Marion Cotillard will be playing Talia Al Ghul in the upcoming The Dark Knight Rises, the final installment of Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy, I had the following admittedly somewhat misogynistic thought: "But Talia Al Ghul is supposed to have big boobs!"

Immediately upon having this thought it occurred to me that, in comics, every female character has big boobs (or at least they are drawn that way; I have never seen a superheroine's cup size expressly referred to in either the dialogue or the narration of a comic book, or a supervillainess's for that matter) and yet I have never had this particular qualm about the casting of a female comic book character before.

I am perfectly OK with Anne Hathaway (whom I estimate to be a large B cup) as Catwoman, although I cannot imagine her being as good as Michelle Pfeiffer (an A cup) in the role. In fact, I have always said that Nicole Kidman circa Eyes Wide Shut would have made a perfect Poison Ivy, and her breasts are no larger than Pfeiffer's. I am in agreement with the rest of the internet that Kristen Bell (another member of the Itty Bitty Titty Committee) would make a crackerjack Harley Quinn, and though I am unhappy with the casting of Amy Adams as Lois Lane in Zack Snyder's upcoming Superman project, it has nothing to do with her endowment or lack thereof (simply put: Lois Lane should have black hair. Did Snyder learn nothing from Bryan Singer's mistake in casting Kate Bosworth, a famous blonde, in the same role five years ago?).

So why then, in the case of Talia Al Ghul, did it matter? At first I thought it might have to do with her characterization in the comics as a sort of hypersensual Jungian earth mother-cum-femme fatale whose most powerful weapon against Batman—even more so than Poison Ivy, who it should be noted has only ever managed to seduce Batman through the application of specially cultivated pheromones, which when you think about it is basically the equivalent of slipping a roofie into his drink—is her femininity. After all, breasts, especially large ones, are the classic symbol of that attribute.

An intriguing thought to be sure, but one that ultimately amounts to pure bullshit. Some of the most devastatingly feminine sirens of the silver screen—indeed, some of the most devastatingly feminine women I have been fortunate enough to know in private life—have managed to become so despite the handicap of a modest bust size, proving, really, that it is no handicap at all.

No, I think the real reason is this: whereas Catwoman, Poison Ivy, Harley Quinn and Lois Lane all have other distinctive visual characteristics by which they can be readily identified (respectively: a pointy-eared mask, green skin and red hair, a black and red bodysuit with pigtail-like pompoms, and a Murphy Brownesque skirt-suit and tumbling raven locks inspired by those of none other than Joanne Siegel, wife of Superman co-creator Jerry Siegel, which is exactly what makes the thought of changing them now so positively blasphemous), Talia Al Ghul has no such physical trademarks. No garish costume, no disfiguring scars, no stylized insignia emblazoned on her chest. When she appears in the comics it is in any one of a wide variety of outfits ranging from black leather catsuits to elegant designer gowns to safari ensembles reminiscent of Indiana Jones. Even her hair color fluctuates randomly between red, black and brown (though, interestingly, never blonde; there are very few blondes Gotham City. Harley Quinn is the only one I can think of off the top of my head, and even then her hair is covered up most of the time. What’s up with that?).

This is strikingly unusual for such a profoundly visual medium. The language of comics is a language of symbols, of iconography. It has to be. Styles change, artists come and go. We recognize Batman and Superman not by the features of their faces but by their coloring, their costumes and the symbols on their chests. After all, the features of their faces are largely uniform—which is why, when watching an episode of The New Batman Superman Adventures with my five year-old niece last week, she asked if Batman and Superman were brothers. Stick them in street clothes and you wouldn’t be able to tell the two apart. That is unless Superman was wearing his Clark Kent glasses, in which case you’d know straight away who was who. That’s why Lois Lane has been falling for the same cheap disguise for the last seventy years. The glasses make all the difference.

The same goes for the women; hide their hair under a baseball cap, apply a little concealer to Poison Ivy’s skin, and you couldn’t  tell the difference between Poison Ivy and Harley Quinn—or Harley Quinn and Catwoman, or Catwoman and Lois Lane, or Lois Lane and Wonder Woman, or Wonder Woman and Batgirl, or Batgirl and Zatanna, or Zatanna and Huntress, or Huntress and Power Girl, or Power Girl and Super Girl, or Super Girl and Black Canary.


See? Without the helpful little clues, you wouldn't know who was who, would you?

Luckily, in costume, which is how they appear 99% of the time, they all have their own distinctive visual characteristics, their own personal visual iconography.


All except Talia. As Forest Gump would say: “Talia Al Ghul is like a box of chocolates; you never know what you’re gonna get.”

At least, you never know what you’re gonna get besides a nice, big, heaving pair of breasts.


Or if you want to stick with the "box of chocolates" analogy: Mamelons de Vénus.

After being conditioned by years of reading comic books to latch onto exactly one distinctive visual characteristic for every character I encountered and then forever after to identify them by that characteristic, is it any wonder that, upon encountering a character with no consistent visual characteristic besides that of her extremely large breasts, I would come to think of that characteristic as being an integral part of her iconography, even if that was never the intention of any of the artists who depicted her that way, and even if there is, after all, no legitimate artistic or literary justification for my thinking so?

This leads me back to an interesting debate I once had with my sister: Would casting Beyonce Knowles, or another black actress, in the role of Wonder Woman, a character who has traditionally been depicted as white, be wrong?

I said yes. My sister said no. She argued that there was nothing inherent in either the character’s personality or her background that required she be white. I argued that, while that would be true had the character originated in film or television (in which case her race would have been an accident of casting) or prose (in which case her race, ignoring the hypothetical in which the plot of the short story or novel in which she first appeared dealt directly with the issue thereof, would have been irrelevant and probably left unspecified), the fact remained that she had originated in comics, which is not just a visual medium but a medium in which the visuals, by virtue of the fact that they are drawn, are determined every bit as much by design, and have behind them every bit as much artistic intention, as the story or the dialogue. Indeed, when you consider that a comic book without visuals would not be a comic book at all but a work of prose, whereas a comic book without dialogue or narration would still, assuming the visuals were arranged in such a way that they told a story, be a comic book, you could argue that the visuals are the single most important aspect of that medium, and by extension, of any character arising from that medium—including, in the case of Wonder Woman, her white skin and black hair.

To this my sister rebutted that whenever she thought of Wonder Woman, the visuals that occurred to her were not her white skin and black hair but her golden tiara and silver wristbands—which was, even if I do suspect she was lying, a fair point. After all, if Beyonce Knowles were to appear before me right now wearing nothing but said tiara and wristbands, it would take me exactly zero seconds to identify which character she was portraying, regardless of whether or not I happened to approve of her portraying that character (and to say nothing of the other feelings that image would arouse).

It was at this point that my sister, who does not share my taste for debating, declared the subject closed, and stated that she would rather simply agree to disagree, it being perfectly OK for different people to have differing opinions, and an important skill in life being that of encountering people with differing opinions without feeling the need to convince them of the wrongness of their opinions and the rightness of your own, because really there is no so such thing as rightness or wrongness, all things being, when you come right down to it, matters of opinion, and opinions being very subjective and personal things, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera.

Truth be told, the frustrating lack of closure I routinely experience in debating with my sister was a major impetus behind my creating this blog. Case in point: she loves Twilight.


Had she been willing to continue with the debate, however, what I would have said then is this: while it may be true that Wonder Woman’s tiara and wristbands are the more iconic of her visual characteristics than her white skin and black hair, her white skin and black hair are still, nevertheless, iconic, meaning that, since it was announced that a Wonder Woman project was in the works, the public has quite naturally been expecting the producers of the film to cast a white-skinned, black-haired actress in the eponymous role. Therefore, were said producers now to cast a black-skinned, black-haired actress, the public would Take Notice. And Taking Notice, they would Make Inferences as to the producers’ Motivations. And the Motivations the public inferred the producers had would doubtless be that the producers wished to Make A Statement. And the Statement that the public inferred the producers’ wished to make would just as doubtless be that a black woman can be just as strong, brave and heroic as a white woman. And the public would be right. And all of this would be a distraction from what the most important issue really is, which is the effectiveness of the movie as a piece of entertainment. And I don’t like my politics, however commendable they may be, mixing with my entertainment.

Now, don’t get me wrong. The above statement is absolutely true. Of course a black woman can be just as strong, brave and heroic as a white woman. Indeed, a black woman can be just as strong, brave and heroic as Wonder Woman. She just can’t be Wonder Woman.

Why? Because Wonder Woman is white. That is simply a fact, established empirically by seventy years worth of drawings. Yes, yes, the period of time during which she was conceived was a period of time when most people would probably have disagreed with the statement that a black woman can be just as strong, brave and heroic as a white woman, and that is a shameful thing, and I am glad to be alive during a time that is much more enlightened, but the comics industry has since atoned for that sin by creating many new, original black superheroes and –heroines, and if none of them has quite managed to attain the pop-cultural status of Wonder Woman, well then it is surely not because they are black but because Wonder Woman came first, a fact which, barring the invention of time travel, it is simply too late to remedy.

The most eloquent expression of a comic cook character’s essence will always be that character’s image. No story, no essay, no performance by any actor or actress, black or white, will ever come close to conveying as much about who that character is, what they represent, and what they have come to mean to their fans, as that. It is, after all, to the image of these characters that we fans are most devoted. It’s why we hang their posters on our walls, why the average comic book fan will be able to name many more artists than he can writers, and why we argue endlessly over which artists have done the best job of rendering them over the years, whose version is our favorite.

And it’s why we argue just as endlessly over who should be cast in the roles when those characters make the tall-building-spanning-leap to the big screen. Perhaps you’ve noticed, if you’ve ever browsed through the comments section of a website like comicsalliance.com and comicbookmovie.com, that we don’t, for better or worse, seem to care very much about things like acting ability or level of celebrity.

No, what we really care about is does the actor or actress look the part. That’s the reason we go to see these movies: to see those posters on our walls come to life. Sure, Heath Ledger’s performance as the Joker in The Dark Knight was brilliantly nuanced and psychologically complex, and all those lines in the script like “I’m an agent of chaos” and “This is what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object” and “You know what I am? I’m a dog chasing cars—I wouldn’t know what to do with one if I caught it!” were nice (and of course the pencil trick ranks among the greatest anarchic Joker moments of any Joker story in any medium) but do you think we would have cared about any of that if he hadn’t looked right?




Green hair, white skin, red lips. That’s all we ask. We didn’t even mind when they changed his origin story (really, eliminated it altogether) or made his green hair, white skin and red lips mere makeup as opposed to the results of chemical scarring—just as long as he still had them.

Likewise, I couldn’t care less that the current incarnation of Wonder Woman, as played by Adrianne Palicki and penned by Ally McBeal scribe David E. Kelley for NBC, has her back story changed from “Amazonian princess” to “corporate executive" because I’ve seen this:



And just so you don’t think they forgot about the silver wristbands:

See? There they are! Right there!

She looks great! In fact, what upset me far more than hearing about the change Kelley had made to her back story for the TV series was hearing about the change—or redesign, as such things are called—that artist Jim Lee had made to her costume in the comic books, replacing her star-spangled blue bikini bottom (or skirt or loincloth, as they were sometimes drawn depending on the artist and era) with long, skintight black pants, changing the color of her wristbands from silver to gold, and covering her previously bare arms and shoulders with a black leather jacket:



Of course, these things happen from time to time in comics and I’m sure that she’ll be back in her vintage threads in no time. My point is that when it comes to superhero mythology, the costume is more important than the identity of the person inside it—and as much as it may not be politically correct to say so, hair color and, yes, skin color, are as much a part of a superhero’s costume as the color of his or her cape and tights.

Though I admit cup size may be taking things a bit too far.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

What is this, comedy?




Imagine an episode of Monty Python’s Flying Circus guest directed by David Lynch and guest starring Andy Kaufman. Now imagine that immediately after watching that episode you fall asleep and have nightmares about it, and in your nightmares there are two Andy Kaufmans, one short, babyfaced and blond, the other tall, lumbering, bespectacled and brunette—a sort of modern day George and Lennie from Of Mice and Men if George and Lennie were hipsters and George was also retarded.




Congratulations! You’ve just imagined Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job!, a sketch comedy series produced by, created by, directed by and starring college buddies Tim Heidecker and Eric Wareheim that aired for five seasons on Cartoon Network’s after-hours network-within-a-network Adult Swim before its cancellation in May of last year.

Very probably it's an exercise in futility to attempt to analyze the comedic stylings of Tim Heidecker and Eric Wareheim, or as they’re simply referred to among their fan base, Tim and Eric (pronounced as one word, “Timmuhneric”, almost as if they were one entity). At first glance it all seems so obvious, so uninhibitedly stream-of-consciousness, that to do so would be to miss the point: to apply too much thought to a brand of humor of which the chief appeal is that it requires no thought. But I will attempt to do just that, because I believe that over the course of its five seasons the recognition it received was criminally less than the recognition it deserved, and I intend to remedy that in whatever inconsequential way I can by wielding my considerable non-influence as one of the literally millions of anonymous bloggers currently dumping their teaspoons of opinionated water into the journalistic ocean of the internet.

My friend Larry likes to tell the story of how the first time he saw TaEAS,GJ! he was too busy marveling at the fact that he had never seen his own esoteric sense of humor captured so perfectly on screen to laugh.


He even sort of looks like Tim!

My first experience watching TaEAS,GJ! was similar, except that in my case it didn’t prevent me from partaking in more than my fair share of lolz (alright, that will officially be the last time you see me resorting to LOL speak on this blog, and if you ever catch me using it again you have my permission to find out where I live, drive to my apartment and personally bust an anticonformist cap in my pandering ass). The sense of humor that so impressed my friend Larry and me I would describe as this: the amplification of everything that is awkward, pompous, banal and dehumanizing about television culture, particularly sitcoms, public access channels and infomercials, augmented by the juxtaposition with that culture of subject matter that is usually considered too taboo, sensitive or shocking, enhanced by a preoccupation with gross-out humor, slapstick and bad puns. Others have used terms like absurdism, Dadaism, satire, camp and anti-humor, but I would substitute the term meta-humor, a term I rather optimistically hoped I might have invented but a quick Googling just now informed me not only already exists but even has its very own Wikipedia page (although to my credit, none of the styles of joke described on that that page is the type to which I am referring).

When I say “meta-humor” what I mean is that the central joke of the series seemed at times to be that it wasn't funny. It was as if you the audience and Tim and Eric the performers were laughing together at a hypothetical third party who did find it funny, although at other times it felt uncomfortably like Tim and Eric were laughing at you for thinking you were in on the joke when really you were as much the butt of it as that hypothetical third party, which of course only resulted in more laughter, albeit of a decidedly different sort.

What made the show truly genius, though, is that Tim and Eric managed to accomplish all this without ever acting smug, or breaking character, or winking at the camera, or exchanging knowing glances, or resorting to any of the other tactics most satirists or “camp” comedians use to indicate to their audiences that they consider themselves above their material, so much so that I often find myself chuckling aloud at a comment one of them makes in a magazine or on a TV talk show that someone less familiar with their comedy would have read as perfectly straight, and for all I know was perfectly straight, except that I’ve been conditioned never to trust anything that comes out of their mouths as genuine.

Even the death of one of their frequent cast mates, Richard Dunn, wasn’t enough to convince me of their sincerity. I remember laughing despite myself upon reading a comment that Tim had posted to his Twitter—or was to their website?—addressing it, something along the lines of “Eric and I are deeply saddened to learn of the death of Richard Dunn . . . He was a very special friend and a very special spirit xoxo”.


Richard Dunn, 1936-2010
A very special friend and
a very special spirit
xoxo

It was the “xoxo” that did it. And frankly, I don’t blame him if the comment wasn’t sincere, because it seems only right that he should memorialize his friend according to the sensibilities of the show on which they collaborated, one of those sensibilities being that any display of pomp is necessarily self-parodying, and another being that there is nothing funnier under the sun than a thing which other people take seriously. In fact, I am fond of saying that if the Joker watched TV then his favorite show would be TaEAS,GJ!, which is pretty damn high praise indeed coming from me, as twisted as that sounds.

Can’t you just imagine him laughing his abnormally long head off at sketches like this:




I compared the pair to David Lynch earlier, and in their commitment to unsettling, hallucinatory surrealism it is that director to whom they are indeed most comparable, but there is something Coenesque about them as well, in their nihilism, their indiscriminate misanthropy, although the Coen brothers themselves have balked at the use of those terms to describe their work, insisting that their scathing mockery of their characters is ultimately affectionate. One gets the feeling that Tim and Eric would make similar assurances, and considering that their demeanors are so unflaggingly jovial one would be inclined to believe them. But use those terms I will, for when a comedian aims such merciless ridicule so liberally at so many targets then there must be something of the misanthrope about him, even if he is good enough to have a sense of humor about it.

I can imagine the pair getting on well with Jeff Bridges’s “The Dude” from what is probably the Coen brother’s most beloved movie, though not necessarily their most accomplished, The Big Lebowski, who similarly saw through the affectations and plagiaristic passions of those around him, but rather than getting angry instead chose to sit back, light up a “jay” or mix himself a White Russian, and shake his head amusedly. Don’t think for a moment, though, that perpetually laid-back stoner types escaped the eagle eye of their derision, either:




There is another aspect to their comedy that I have failed to mention, which, in truth, is probably the aspect my friend Larry responded to even more than the misanthropy, the Lynchian surrealism or the meta-humor. Rather than immediately launch into trying to define it, however, I will instead share with you a personal anecdote:

Back in high school, I accepted a ride home from a party one night with an attractive female friend of mine. After we had pulled up to the curb in front of my house we continued to sit in the car and talk as two friends will, and over the course of the conversation I brought up my cousin Jacob--only, for whatever reason, my mouth turned traitor and formed the wrong vowel subsequently to pronouncing the letter "J". As a result, instead of beginning my cousin's name with the syllable "Jay" as would have been in accordance with tradition, I began it with the syllable "Jah". Realizing my mistake, I attempted to correct my mispronunciation midway through the first syllable, so that my cousin's name came out sounding like this: "Jahaaaycob." Given the choice between ignoring what had just occurred and acknowledging the fact that for a moment there I had sounded like one of the cast of The Beverly Hillbillies, both my friend and I chose to ignore it, which resulted in there being a palpable awkwardness between us for the remainder of the conversation from which my night never recovered.

Tim and Eric would have found this hilarious. In fact, had their cameras been rolling, they would have slapped a subtitle on the screen at the precise moment I said my cousin's name just to draw further attention to my mispronunciation of it, as they did whenever someone on their show got tongue-tied, stuttered, or simply pronounced a word in a way that they thought was weird.

This celebration, this pointing out, of those small moments of absurdity that most people either ignore or just plain fail to notice, and the two friends' obvious delight in them, is one of the pair's most endearing qualities. It also made for some of the shows funniest gags, as when guest star Zach Galifianakis, who is supposed to be playing a character named "Terry Green", when introducing himself sounds more like he's saying "Tairy", and this is pointed out to the audience by means of, you guessed it, a subtitle. Or when in another collaboration with Galfianakis, a short film they made for Absolut Vodka called A Vodka Movie, Galifianakis serves them cartoonishly large martini glasses filled with Absolut on ice and the following exchange takes place:

TIM: What is this, ice?

ZACH: Um, Absolut on ice.

TIM: Ah.

Now that may not be very funny in print, but trust me, on film it's hilarious. It is also the kind of joke (if you can even call it a "joke") that no one would ever think to write into a script. Luckily, A Vodka Movie is entirely improvised, and out of all the many minutes and possibly even hours of footage that wound up on the proverbial cutting room floor, the filmmakers chose to include that brief and utterly mundane exchange.

Why did they? Well, my friend Larry and I have spent hours trying to answer that question--to figure out just what makes it so gosh darn funny--and this is what we've come up with:

In the film, when Tim asks the question "What is this, ice?" it seems apparent that he is asking not what the drink is that Zach has served them but referring to the ice itself, asking if that is, indeed, what it is. Zach, by responding, "Um, Absolut on ice," would then be betraying himself as having misunderstood Tim's question. But then Tim, instead of explaining to Zach that what he was actually referring to was the ice, simply lets Zach continue to think that he was referring to the drink, and the misunderstanding goes unacknowledged.

This is funny for several reasons:

1) "What is this, ice?" is a stupid thing to ask, as the ice is obviously ice.

2) If Tim had indeed been asking "What is this drink you have served us, ice?" then that would have been an even stupider thing to ask, since A) ice is not a drink, B) it is obvious that there is more than just ice in the glass, and C) Zach has already told him what it is by the time this exchange takes place.

3) If "What is this drink you have served us, ice?" is indeed a stupid question to ask for all the reasons expounded upon in #2, then it was as stupid of Zach to assume that that was what Tim was asking as it would have been of Tim to ask it.

4) If that is indeed what Zach thought Tim was asking, then surely he too must have thought it was a stupid thing to ask, and yet he pretends not to.

5) Upon realizing that Zach thought he was asking if the drink was ice, Tim himself must have felt embarrassed that Zach thought he was asking such a stupid question, and yet he pretends not to, perhaps because he is so embarrassed that he simply wants to move on to another subject, perhaps because he doesn't want to hurt Zach's feelings by correcting him.

6) It is stupid to be embarrassed over such a small thing.

7) It is stupid to try to assuage your embarrassment by changing the subject when simply explaining that you were not asking what the other person thinks you were asking would do a better job of it, as that would eliminate your reason for being embarrassed in the first place.

8) It is stupid to think that someone's feelings would be hurt by your merely explaining to them that they had misunderstood your question.

9) After all that misunderstanding, and all that embarrassment, and all that pretense, the amount of information communicated is so minuscule, so utterly inconsequential, that the exchange might as well not have taken place at all.

Now, am I suggesting that all or even some of this went through the heads of the performers, either when they spoke those lines or when they decided to leave them in the film? Of course not. Nor am I suggesting that it goes through the heads of the people who watch it and laugh at it (at least not consciously). I'm sure that if you asked any of them, performer or audience member, why it was funny, they would respond the same way: "It just is!" And who knows, maybe that's the better answer. Hell, they might even respond that it wasn't funny, because, after all, humor is irreconcilably subjective, and there's no better way to ensure that someone will continue to think something isn't funny than by trying to explain to them why it is.

And so, in that spirit, rather than continue trying to explain to you why Tim and Eric's comedy is funny, I will simply invite you to see for yourself by going out and buying one of their DVDs. Or better yet, thanks to the miracle of the internet, you can watch any one of their sketches here. Or check out their wubsite.

Er, I mean website.

Friday, February 18, 2011

A Many-Splendored Thing Pt. 2.5

I am not going to continue with my list of the Top Ten Depictions of blah blah blah because I have grown bored with it.

And as I currently have all of two followers, both of whom are friends of mine, I don't expect to disappoint anyone.

I will, however, provide the rest of the list right now sans explanations, and if someday in the future, after I have amassed thousands of followers, one of them should be browsing through my back catalog of entries and come upon this entry, and if he or she should see an item on that list that they would have liked to read my thoughts on, then he or she may leave a comment saying so, and I will most likely oblige them.

So, here they are: the final eight.


8) Chasing Amy, written and directed by Kevin Smith

7) The relationship between Batman and Catwoman, as written (and occasionally directed) by various

6) "If I Loved You" from Carousel, music by Richard Rogers and lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein

5) The couples of Mad Men, as written and directed by Matthew Weiner and various

4) Wuthering Heights, by Emily Brontë

3) Say Anything, written and directed by Cameron Crowe

2) Moulin Rouge!, written by Baz Luhrmann and Craig Pearce and directed by Baz Luhrmann

1) The Last 5 Years, music and lyrics by Jason Robert Brown


Now that that's out of the way I can move onto bigger and better things, like writing about how fly Michael Fassbender looks dressed as a 19th century British lord. (Spoiler alert: pretty fucking fly.)

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

A Many-Splendored Thing Pt. 2


9) The "Doug & Patti Sittin' in a Tree" episode of Nickelodeon's Doug, written by Matt Steinglass and directed by Ken Kimmelman


Between the years 1991 and 1994 Nickelodeon's Doug was the single greatest cartoon on television, and yes, I am prepared to stand by the statement. It had a cast of characters to rival that of The Simpsons and took place in an imaginary town called Bluffington with as clear a sense of its own geography and almost as many familiar locations as that other show's Springfield, and at the center of it all was an eleven year-old protagonist who was far more sympathetic to preadolescent audiences than his more famous counter-Bart could ever be.



His name was Doug Yancey Funnie. He kept a journal, played the banjo, had a slew of Hollywood-inspired alter egos, an anthropomorphic dog named Porkchop, and most importantly a crush on the spunky, sporty, raspy-voiced Patti Mayonnaise. Over the course of four seasons we watched him struggle to understand these new and sometimes frightening feelings, as well as try and fail countless times to find a way to express them to Patti.

Then this happened:



"You know, your grass is really...springy!"
"Yeah, they water it...a lot."

Until now I hadn't seen that episode for twelve years, and yet I could still have recited those two lines for you verbatim. That's the impression it made on me. It just does so many things right! Capturing that inexplicable feeling of shame you felt as a kid at the idea that your parents might suspect you were interested in the opposite sex, the reluctance even to admit it to yourself because, in some small way you couldn't quite put your finger on, it meant the end of your childhood, which is a kind of loss, the absolute bafflement you felt in the face of a whole new world with its own indecipherable set of rules and rituals, not knowing where to turn for help in deciphering them, afraid to ask, afraid of being laughed at, afraid that you would never understand...

But most of all what it captures perfectly is the feeling of looking into the face of someone you love, or at least to whom you are intensely attracted, having every reason in the world to believe that they feel the same way, knowing all that separates you from the consummation of that mutual attraction is for one of you to take the leap, to make the first move, to speak the unspoken, and still being unable to bring yourself to speak it, because it's just too damn big, because it means the end of everything you know and the beginning of everything that scares you, because it means there will be no hiding anymore, no going back, because it means that everything is going to change forever...

...so instead you comment on the grass, or offer them a gummy bunny.

A Many-Splendored Thing




These days everyone seems to hate Valentine's Day.

But if there's one thing that everyone seems to love, it's "top ten" lists.

So, in honor of Valentine's Day--and because, for a wet-behind-the-ears blogger like myself, it's an easy and familiar template--I decided to compile a list of the Top Ten Depictions of Love in Popular Culture.

"Depictions?" you ask. "Why 'depictions'?"

Well, rather than limit myself to just one medium--movies, songs, TV shows, comic books, etc.--I decided to leave it open, if only because I stated in my last entry that this was not going to be a film blog, and posting a list of the ten best movies about love immediately after stating that this is not going to be a film blog, well, that would be sending mixed messages, wouldn't it?

And if there's one day on which you're not supposed to send mixed messages, it's Valentine's Day.

So, without further ado, I present to you the first entry in my list of the Ten Best Depictions of Love in Popular Culture:

10) The relationship between Belle and the Beast in Beauty and the Beast, as written by Linda Woolverton, directed by Gary Trousdale and Kirk Wise and acted by Paige O'Hara and Robby Benson



I put this at the bottom of the list because, as has been pointed out many times before, Belle and the Beast's relationship is a little, well, fucked up.

The way they meet is as follows: He kidnaps her father, she shows up at his castle in search of him, and he (the Beast) releases him (Belle's father) on the condition that she remain in his place, in the hope that, after enough time spent in his company, voluntarily or otherwise, she may fall in love with him.

Not exactly a story you can tell at dinner parties. In fact, except for the part about kidnapping her father, it's pretty much exactly the plot of The Collector by John Fowles, one of the creepiest novels ever. The difference is that, whereas in The Collector the girl winds up (SPOILER ALERT!) dead, in Beauty and the Beast it actually works, and one escape attempt/wolf attack/thrilling rescue later we are treated to one of the sweetest, most believably intimate scenes in any romantic movie ever:





You see, fucked up as the origin of their relationship may be, Beauty and the Beast is the only Disney Princess movie in which the heroine and her respective love interest actually have a relationship, fucked up or nay, which would have been enough to earn it a spot on this list alone. But what's more, when it would have been all too easy to fall into the trap of having her fall in love with him at least a little bit because he is a beast, as with certain other pieces of popular fiction marketed towards young girls, Belle's affection for the Beast is always markedly in spite of his beastly qualities, as over the course of the film she responds to those qualities first with genuine and wholly unerotic terror, and then, after she has learned that, despite his appearance, his outbursts are not the displays of aggression of a dangerous predator but the temper tantrums thrown by a petulant child, annoyance. The arc of their relationship is that she must learn to see through his temper tantrums and defense mechanisms to the lonely, insecure little boy underneath, while he must learn to control his temper and lower his defense mechanisms, thereby making himself vulnerable, probably for the first time in his life, to another person.

In order for the Beast to earn the love of the Beauty, he must first learn to stop acting like a beast, something that, in the end, he is only able to do because of the love of the Beauty, in the form of her forgiveness.

If that’s not romantic, I don’t know what is.